killerisdeadlogo

Is Killer is Dead dead on arrival? Check out our review of Suda51’s latest entry in the hack n’ slash genre to find out if it’s worth your time.

Greetings Internet.  Ever had a creator or group of creators you really wanted to like, but the majority of their work just doesn’t seem to stack up to your expectations?  Originally bumped into popularity by his cult hit Killer7 and continued success with titles like No More Heroes and Lollipop Chainsaw, Suda51 is that creator for me.  While his games receive mixed to positive reviews from others, for me the majority of his work is lacking.  That said, his latest title has been out long enough for the opinions to be solidified.  So, let’s talk about Killer Is Dead

[youtube http://youtu.be/A0p9e01Pxvs]

Right away I find it hard to even outline the game, the setting itself confuses me out of the gate. I don’t know if this is a modern fantasy present or future, should I even classify it as fantasy?  It has sci-fi elements as well, but like a lot of the games’ other aspects, nothing seems very cohesive.  You play Mondo Zappa, an “executioner” who works for the Executioner Office, an organization hired by apparently anybody to kill targets.  I say “apparently” because the office supposedly is controlled by the state, what state I don’t know.  They use real world location names, but their own location is never clear and they apparently have no limit to their jurisdiction.  I’m probably not supposed to be thinking this hard about it, but I want to stress one of the main problems with this game; it’s nearly incomprehensible.

Attempting to give a basic outline of the plot would boil down to saying “you go kill people you’re hired to kill” which is too vague to mean much of anything, but to be more specific would be to start detailing the plot full on.  There’s a villain, though his part in the events is loose at best and I don’t recall any of the clients who come to the office actually ever paying for your services.  At times you go into Mondo’s dreams, but I still don’t know what I was supposed to take away from it. The connection to the total sum of events in the story is loose.  OK, normally I’m the type of gamer who doesn’t really care about story quality, I admit that, a bad story can be ignored if a game is enjoyable to play… so let’s trudge straight into the other main problem

killer-is-dead-2 l_50f6d3e5195d7.

The game is a hack n’ slash, in the vein of Devil May Cry, but unlike the compared game, is not the least bit dynamic or stylish and lacks variety.  You have your main weapon, a katana, and your bio-mechanical left arm, which transforms into several sub weapons, though you start with only one; a rapid fire gun.  You gain crystals from defeated enemies and can use them to pay for new skills and to upgrade current skills.  Some skills and all sub weapons are powered by “blood” which is also gained from defeated enemies, though what they drop is random.  This all sounds very standard… because it is, extremely standard. In fact, boringly so.  You start with a few of your skills that can be upgraded, and the rest are either healing related, or add only slightly new moves to your combat selection, the only real standout skill being a counter attack.  Combat feels stiff and distant and ultimately, repetitive. The sub weapons bring little to the table, leaving you using your main weapon for the majority of the game.  If you ever found a Dynasty Warriors game dull, this isn’t doing any better.

[youtube http://youtu.be/yuPYdTpEDqc]

Of course one of the things Suda51 is known for is his bizarre and striking style and the game does not want for style. In fact, it at times gets in the way…  Odd graphical punctuations when defeating groups of enemies, a fidgety camera (though by no means one of the worst) and at times, painful choice in colorization made me glad to fight in bland open rooms to save myself the trouble.  Playing this game gives me the impression that it would probably be best if Suda51 had more restraints when designing games, something more subdued would’ve been far more tolerable.  Of course the style would’ve been acceptable if the gameplay had been more enjoyable and diverse, but I’ve already discussed that.

I bought the special edition of the game which came with an art book and soundtrack CD.  This is the first time I ever felt like my special edition purchase was a waste; aside from the art book holding little interest due to the characters lacking much character in the mess that is the story, the game’s music doesn’t stand out either,  I can’t recall a single tune off the top of my head.  The sad truth is that there isn’t a single standout feature of this game… well, I guess there’s one…

The game has four things to do, three of which; story missions, side missions, and the “arena”, are just more combat.  Then there’s the fourth… activity.  Gigolo missions.  I really had hoped, when first told about these, that it was some kind of a joke, that it wasn’t really going to be something as shallow as had been described to me, but they are.  Gigolo missions find you seducing women… by looking at them.  Not just looking, leering, really, full on, leering.  You are nothing but a camera, zooming in and out at the girl, earning points for looking at the right parts at the right time, earn enough points and you get to give the girl a present to buy her affection!  There have been games in the past that were criticized for doing little but objectify women (DOA Xtreme Beach Volleyball comes to mind), heck, we had ourselves a gaming controversy very recently with Dragon’s Crown.  But this, this isn’t just putting women in skimpy outfits for the potential objectification by a male player, this takes away any choice you might have had in the matter, the goal of this mode is to objectify, pure and simple.  It really isn’t out of line to call this sexist, especially when you’re told that you can buy a pair of glasses that lets you look at the girls in their underwear.  The real kicker?  I mentioned earlier that you start with only one sub weapon, well the only way to acquire more is to complete gigolo missions.  So if you want to add even a sliver of variety to combat, you have to play these.

[youtube http://youtu.be/yKvv4mjou7k]

I haven’t been so happy to remove a game from a console in a long time.  What really pains me, even more then the gigolo missions, is how derivative the game feels. Tt somehow feels like Suda is ripping himself off, from the style and obfuscated story telling, all the way down to the title, Killer Is Dead, which feels desperate to evoke memories of Killer7, a good game.  For a creator who is often seen as producing unique and strange titles, it seems the most damning critique of his work.  Suda51 can make enjoyable games, but lately it feels like he isn’t trying. In fact, the only recent title of his I’ve liked is a little known download only for the 3DS; Liberation Maiden.  For those of you curious, go try it, it’s worth it, Killer Is Dead, however, is not worth the purchase.  I can only hope for better from Suda in the future, until then, good gaming everyone.

Killer is Dead Review

Advertisements

6 comments

  1. I am still fascinated with Killer7. That game is a macabre poem. I have no idea what it means, but I loved it, even though the gameplay is lacking.

    I love No More Heroes. The characters areso fascinating, and the story is so bonkers. It’s the Kill Bill of video games.

    If I had more free time, I’d at least give Killer is Dead a shot. Unfortunately, I have to make an educated guess through videos and reviews, which are almost universally negative.

    I’m not even sure what Killer is Dead *is* and I’m not sure if Suda51 does either. The video I saw on Kotaku made it look like, “Let’s throw a bunch of crap at the screen and see what sticks.” Nothing sticks, and we’re just left with a bunch of crap on our screen. It’s a shame.

    Thanks for the thoughtful review.

    1. I admit I still need to actually finish Killer7 myself, sitting amongst my huge piles of unfinished games, but everything about it is unique and imaginative, which sadly seems to have slowly seeped out of each subsequent game Suda has made. I really wanted to like KID, but it just wasn’t happening, I’ll keep hoping Suda turns it around though. Thanks for the words!

  2. Suda Goichi (I’m not ever going to call him 51) has always seemed like that guy in high school that sits around getting attention for being zany, but does it only for attention. We all know someone like that. Consequently, the two of his games I’ve played (Heroes, and Chainsaw) only struck me on that one level. Really zany, but nothing interesting about them. Nothing to hold my attention once I realized it was all an act. Sounds like Killer is Dead is just the same thing over again. I am at least interested in going back and giving Killer7 a try though.

    1. I feel like Suda has turned into that type of person over time, and I wonder what the reason behind it is, but as it stands all I can do is wait for any given game and hope that it turns out better then the last. I maintain that he can make good games, that’s why I recommended Liberation Maiden, it’d just be nice to see him do it more frequently. Thanks for the words.

    1. Yah, that’s pretty much how I felt the majority of the time playing the game, just a constant sense of “there are no words”.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s